The myth of the suffering artist

Film

Détails

Pushing Yourself Without Breaking: A Conversation with Michel Brais

Part 1

For several years, we at the Coop Vidéo de Montréal have been working with Michel Brais, a psychotherapist who specializes in supporting artists. When we met, I was looking for someone who could help me develop a new approach to the relationship between filmmakers and producers. In particular, I was trying to solve a problem that weighed on me: how to keep pushing ourselves to keep up with the industry’s pace without burning out. I was coming out of a few years during which I had supported several filmmakers through rough patches, and when I burned out myself, it led me to reflect on the industry as a whole and on the dynamic we were all caught up in. The mountain to climb suddenly seemed higher than ever, and I realized, perhaps a little late, that I would never reach the summit, but that this was exactly what making films is. So I began to give more weight to the state of mind of filmmakers and producers, to their mental and physical health, so that we could keep doing what we do with the same level of intensity… forever… From then on, a question began to emerge: how could I meet this need on my own? What was my ultimate responsibility as a producer? What was my job? Defending a filmmaker’s vision? Supporting them emotionally? Closing a budget? Everything else? All of it at once?

When I met Michel, it was an intellectual crush. His vision of the arts community and his ideas about collaborative dynamics answered my many questions almost point by point. I gradually realized that his thinking offered nothing less than a working framework, even an approach to collaboration that allows artists to find a strong, resilient stance in the face of the challenges of creation. We wanted to take stock of this collaboration and, above all, make it public.

What follows is the first part of a conversation that took place in Montreal on May 8, 2026, between Michel and Hany Ouichou, artistic director of the Coop. The conversation has been edited for clarity and concision.

The second part will focus on the workshops that grew out of it at the Coop Vidéo.

Hany: First, I’d like us to go back to the very beginning. How did your practice as a psychotherapist come to intersect with the cultural world?

Michel: It started with my master’s thesis. My first project was on actor training. I began looking at training methods, and there are all kinds of them. What I saw everywhere was that the same training doesn’t produce the same results. And as I was starting my training in therapy, I saw there was a subjective factor: if I do a training with the conviction that I’ll succeed, I don’t get the same results as with the same training done with a “meh, what’s the point, it won’t lead anywhere anyway.” So that’s where I come from: the psyche.

I had written that the aim of this research was “to identify the ways of applying a practical approach that draws on the intimate relationship between the person and the character in order to properly mobilize the actor’s creative resources.” First, drawing on research in theatre, pedagogy and psychology, we develop a theoretical framework showing that engaging the actor’s personal dimension is inherent to their creative work. This dimension of the work opens the door to deep resources, but makes the actor particularly vulnerable, which led me to analyze the conditions that make bringing the personal into play healthy and liberating for the actor as a person, rather than needlessly risky and anxiety-inducing. That then made it possible to set out the guidelines for a practice of supporting actors that fully accounts for the resources and demands of the personal dimension.

H: So in other words, there would be an ideal stance for learning, or at least for growing. And that ideal stance is an attitude of openness and vulnerability. Not necessarily one that makes you vulnerable in a harmful way, but for it to happen under the best conditions, it’s important to set up psychological safeguards, or at least to provide psychological support to that actor or artist?

M: Exactly, but there’s one word in what you said that I need to change right away. When I was young, I was an idealist: I was looking for the ideal formula. Now I look for the optimal formula. One of the challenges of creation is precisely to let go of the absolute and the ideal in order to learn to deal with reality.

So if I take my thinking even further, I’d add that working on this necessarily means a relational approach. It means the actor doesn’t train alone to be high-performing. They train to be available to build a healthy, productive, creative and optimal relationship with their creative environment. If the producer, the stage director, the film director, the actors, everyone shares that cohesion, then we look for a way of working together so that each person can go as far as they can. We can’t remove every risk, but we can remove as much as possible of what could be toxic or harmful.

That driving force is what we call the optimal. It’s not an ideal; it’s a way of adapting, of riding the difficult moments and the better ones, so that there’s momentum toward fulfillment. That doesn’t mean there won’t be suffering or difficulty, but we don’t feel it alone. It makes us want to propel ourselves forward rather than propel ourselves in fear and tense up. In dance, I’ve supported many dancers through career transitions because they got injured. Often, they got injured because they pushed themselves even though they weren’t available or ready. Because you have to outdo yourself, you end up breaking. A resilient environment is one that takes care of vulnerability so it can dance, not so it gets crushed. To me it’s common sense, but it doesn’t always happen that way.

H: It’s really interesting to hear you lay out the foundation of your thinking again, because it still aligns completely with my reflection as a producer. I think about this from the perspective of the one doing the training, the one pushing others to outdo themselves, and I wonder how to lead someone to outdo themselves without them breaking. When I met you, the metaphor I’d found to describe my vision was sports. Making films is being a high-level athlete. And a high-level athlete obviously has a team around them: a massage therapist, a therapist, and so on. And I’d say: how is it that we, in film, go through the same level of competition, pressure and failure, stretched over such long periods, and yet there’s no one around filmmakers? Or just the producer, who precisely isn’t equipped for that? And now I see how completely that connects with your idea of the importance of bringing psychological awareness into the relationship. I mean, you were interested in the actor’s work, but ultimately, could this be broadened to any artist in a working relationship?

M: Yes, I call it a creative ecosystem. I see it as co-creation, where everyone has their vulnerability and owns it rather than making others bear it. And everyone self-regulates. One of the workshops I gave at the Coop in 2023 was called “Let’s Regulate One Another.” Because everyone experiences certain anxieties, and often, if they’re poorly regulated, it turns aggressive, it turns awful.

Let me just go back to sports for a moment. I’ve been interested in it; I worked for a long time at the circus school. Even in sports there’s a problem: what kind of psychology? Sports psychologists weren’t considered psychotherapists, because for a long time they were mainly there to boost performance. They worked on symptoms to make the athlete perform. And it didn’t help. When the ideal athlete made one misstep, they collapsed completely. The great sports coaches changed their attitude: the goal is no longer to reach the ideal athlete, but the athlete who is optimal in their performance. They brought in a more relational psychology of performance. Even in sports, there’s been a culture shift toward aiming for the optimal, healthy person, rather than draining them and then giving them psychological tools to push them even further into exhaustion.

H: How do you perceive the state of mind of the cultural and film community in Quebec more specifically, if you’re able to isolate it?

M: There are particularities; the issues in dance aren’t the same as elsewhere. There’s no community without excesses one way or the other. There are confrontational approaches in theatre too. Some stage directors bring people together; others are confrontational. For some, the end justifies the means, and they’ll make actors suffer to squeeze out the juice; others won’t. That exists in film too. But there are also those with a collaborative approach.

Generally speaking, there’s an openness in the arts to considering this alternative approach, but for many, on the condition that we still come out on top. It remains a form of competition. And the more stress there is, like right now, it’s a slump in the arts communities, which I’ve always seen as very community-minded: there’s more rivalry, less funding, less work. That stirs up other fears, other sources of anxiety that need to be regulated so we don’t abandon our values. Because the more resilient the environment, the more it invites us to be resilient too. The less resilient and more anxiety-inducing the environment, the harder it is to self-regulate. We can see that right now there’s a lot of distress and a lot of insecurity. I find that things are running less smoothly. What I hear is: we shoot faster and faster, and we pay people less. Some actors tell me they now earn for a shooting day what they were paid twenty years ago. TV shooting conditions are like working on an assembly line. Some of the people I support individually can self-regulate, become so resilient that they’re not affected. Others are deeply affected.

But that’s life, in that sense. I’m no longer an idealist. There will never be a perfect world, but we have to keep pushing to show that optimal conditions will make all of us better.

H: A lot of what you’re saying resonates with what we’re currently experiencing at the Coop, for producers as much as for artists, I think. But I wonder to what extent we can make a difference at the systemic level in all this?

M: There’s a phrase I often use when people talk to me about their dysfunctional family at a systemic level: you’re wearing yourself out trying to change your family so it becomes functional. But the only real lever we have to change a dysfunctional system is to act functionally ourselves. If I stop playing my dysfunctional systemic role, I stop feeding it. If I’m reactive rather than acting with discernment, I’m getting on the merry-go-round; I’m feeding the dysfunctional merry-go-round. There has to be a significant number of individuals who are receptive, and that creates a ripple effect. Sometimes it happens, and it creates exceptional working conditions. There are wonderful film sets, too.

But I can’t wait for everything outside me to be resilient. I have to work on my own resilience and make a positive contribution by acting functionally to regulate what’s going on, rather than falling into the reactivity that feeds it. It’s hard to change, but when we manage it, it throws everyone off: “What’s going on?” And suddenly, openings start to appear. Because we’re not dysfunctional because we want to be; it’s because some things are wounded. If we do it well, it’s an invitation for the other person to self-regulate, and then for us to regulate together.

H: Hearing you talk about this, I remember one of our first workshops, which tackled the myth of suffering, meaning the idea that an artist must suffer to create. I feel the idea was exactly to create the beginnings of a collective resistance to that dysfunction.

M: There is a suffering inherent to creation: taking the risk of reaching for something vulnerable and sensitive inside myself, then exposing myself to others by giving it form. There’s something sacrificial about it. Few people truly expose themselves to others in such a sensitive way. Especially since it can mean going into parts of yourself where there may be wounds or trauma, and then using that to create.

But we need to eliminate the excess suffering, the kind that comes from dysfunction. If I go into those painful places but feel supported with kindness, I can go even further without it hurting me. If I go there having to fight to be myself, or having to be on the defensive, that’s when we can get hurt. There’s an inherent suffering that can’t be removed, and it isn’t the same for everyone. That doesn’t mean suffering is required. Some people create in pure joy. And sometimes someone will say: that production was painful, that show really stirred things up in me, but I felt supported, the director was so welcoming, it helped me go all the way and dare to expose myself, and I came out of it feeling deeply liberated.

That doesn’t mean the shoot was therapy. In therapy, there’s an accepted agreement that we’re doing it in order to transform. But any life experience can be “therapeutic.” We repair old traumas by living through similar situations, but in a positive way. That’s life.

H: To optimize training, to reuse your words from the beginning, you have to put yourself in a stance of availability or vulnerability. So that’s the necessary suffering: pushing yourself into that position. But then there would be a superfluous suffering that we could eliminate. Can you tell me more?

M: You need resilient conditions so as not to create needless suffering. Pressure, thinking my actors will be better if I make them suffer: that’s not necessary. Or the suffering we put ourselves through with anticipation, apprehension, anxiety. I often say anxious people should be paid triple time, because they work three times harder than everyone else, but needlessly, wondering what’s going to happen tomorrow. It’s not useful, but it can create a lot of suffering. A large part of suffering is tied to resistance, to fear.

I often say that the more essential and important a need is, the more ambivalently it’s experienced, for almost everyone. For example, everyone wants love. But for many people, love is a need perceived as both indispensable and unbearable, precisely because it’s indispensable. So we have to accept a certain amount of suffering: if I love, I may suffer; someone may abandon me. To love is to accept being vulnerable. If I don’t accept being vulnerable, I’ll go into it defensively, and I’ll already be dysfunctional in the relationship. But if both people open up, we’re already safer. If one opens up and the other is strategic, one is in more danger than the other. One is already protecting themselves from suffering, while the other is in it. Imagine what that can generate in your relationships. It’s the same in working relationships.

H: In other words, we come back again to the fact that it’s always relational, and therefore systemic. People are also very much the symptoms, or the reflection, of their environment. The more individuals in the same system can see one another, the easier it is for them to understand the world around them, and the more it allows them to self-regulate. To me, this connects directly to my vision of what a cooperative is, and the Coop specifically. I think that by breaking down the barriers that isolate filmmakers and allowing them to share their experiences, they can regain a kind of control over the system around them.

M: We are the sum of our relationships. Psychology is often defined as the practice of a neutral professional facing an individual, helping them resolve intrapsychic problems. But with the relational approach I advocate, the intrapsychic doesn’t exist. No neural connection forms outside a relational field. So in the approaches I promote, that relational dimension necessarily has to be there. Even in individual therapy, I always explore relationships elsewhere: how we behave in relation to others. Because it’s in relationships that we’re wounded, and it’s in relationships that we heal. In that sense, we have to stop thinking: you’re not functioning, go to therapy to get fixed, then come back and function. That never calls the context into question. It’s always systemic, always intersubjective.

When I worked on site at the National Circus School, I wasn’t doing therapy. I helped circus artists create a certain safety within groups so they could open up about what they were experiencing, and discover they weren’t the only ones, since the triggers are often the same. And together, what can we do? If everyone feels uneasy with a teacher, is there a step to take? A community should be able to stop and question its practices and interactions in light of the goal it’s pursuing. Not thinking everyone will become nice and kind, but so that there’s a culture where we agree to do it. We no longer accept tyrants on the pretext that they write beautiful symphonies. That doesn’t fly anymore, even in sports. It’s an extraordinary opportunity. But where we go to excess is when it’s as if the police step in: you’re no longer allowed not to be nice, you’re cancelled. That doesn’t work. We need to dialogue, question, and talk about it collectively.

And the shortest path to knowing yourself is to take the trouble to know someone else. And the shortest path to knowing someone else is to learn to know yourself. The philosopher Gadamer, who is somewhat at the root of intersubjective approaches, said that it is hermeneutic dialogue that brings truth. Meaning emerges from dialogue. You can’t go off into your corner to fix yourself and then come back. That just says: I’m at fault, I have to become someone else. Some people go to therapy to try to become someone else. A good therapist will welcome them so they learn to accept being themselves. Perhaps by learning another way of communicating, of existing, of taking action.

Because even what I said earlier hasn’t sunk in enough yet: resilience is still presented as an individual function. So I’m at fault for not being resilient. That’s terrible. I contribute to it, but there’s a system that isn’t resilient either. We have to work on both. Not by complaining, but by asking: what can I do to regulate myself? And by regulating myself, I can have an impact on a non-resilient environment. Everyone does it, and everything moves at the same time.


End of Part 1

CONTACT

Pour plus de renseignements :

info@coopvideo.ca
(514) 521-5541